REST & Security: Why HTTP GET is insecure (and the other methods too)

Yesterday René commented that submitting username and password with HTTP GET is insecure, because they are submitted in clear text over the wire as part of the URI.

At the first moment, I did not give some thought about it, because it is known fact that data added to an URI are less secure. They are added to the browser history, are logged in the requests on servers, and every proxy between the user’s browser and the requested server are seeing (and maybe logging) these URI’s too. That’s why HTTP GET is problematic: The credentials are accidentially spread over the whole world, like any other information which are appended to an URI.

In René’s example, he pointed out that a hotspot provider of a public WiFi can easily grab the URIs (and the credentials), and that’s the reason why HTTP GET is insecure. But this is not the whole truth: As soon HTTP data are going over the wire, the data can be fetched from anyone in the chain of the transport, and it doesn’t matter which HTTP method is used.

Some clever guys are running TOR exit nodes and grab the whole traffic through a transparent proxy, and because they have access to the whole traffic, they are able to fetch credentials from these requests. As long as the data are unprotected.

To protect your data, you have two choices: Use HTTPS connections or encrypt the data by yourself (f.e. with JWE). Manually encrypting won’t solve the problem of logging, but it can help to secure the data. But the preferred way is first one, because it solves all the problems of insecure data during their transport, and is really easy to implement. TLS / SSL is a layer between the TCP layer and the HTTP layer, and the whole traffic (the HTTP data) is encrypted. This includes the URI, only the target host is known to everyone involved of the transport

You shouldn’t use HTTP GET to transfer sensitive informations. The browser history is problematic, and the logs on the target server would contain the requested URIs. When developing a RESTful API you must bear this in mind.

Dieser Beitrag wurde unter REST, Security, Server, Web abgelegt und mit , , , verschlagwortet. Setze ein Lesezeichen auf den Permalink.

2 Kommentare zu REST & Security: Why HTTP GET is insecure (and the other methods too)

  1. At this point, using HTTPS is basically a „may as well“ sort of thing, considering it’s so easy to do so and the overhead is comparatively low (in-between-infrastructure caching notwithstanding). It’s definitely best to avoid putting passwords in query strings, just to prevent them showing up in normal server logs (there’s nothing stopping a dev from storing them elsewhere, but still) – so an initial POST in a browser or using headers in a browser-less API client work nicely.

Schreibe einen Kommentar

Deine E-Mail-Adresse wird nicht veröffentlicht. Erforderliche Felder sind mit * markiert.


*